Manchester United’s managerial search has morphed into one of the most intriguing storylines of the season. With Michael Carrick in temporary control and a host of big names in the betting market — from Oliver Glasner to Gareth Southgate — the question now on every United fan’s lips is simple: who will take the job permanently?
Bookmakers currently list the favourites as follows (rounded prices for readability):
In this article we unpack each contender with pros and cons, explain why Carrick currently has an edge, and give our view on who is most likely to walk through the Old Trafford doors as the next permanent manager.
For deeper context on United’s season and tactical needs, check out our Manchester United season review and tactical analysis and the latest on the Premier League managerial carousel across the top six.
Open Account Offer: Bet £10 Get £30 in Free Bets
Min Deposit: £5 – Expiry: 30 days – Min Odds: 1/5 (1.20)
← CLICK TO COPY
Michael Carrick’s odds reflect his proximity to the job. Already in temporary charge, he steadied the ship after the previous departure and has the trust of the dressing room. Players respect him — that intangible currency managers covet — and his familiarity with the club’s culture gives him a head start over outsiders.
Carrick’s calm demeanour and tactical pragmatism have stabilised performances, and that alone is huge for a squad battered by inconsistency. United’s players seem comfortable under his guidance, and that continuity matters when you’re chasing top-four in the Premier League.
Supporters also like a narrative: a club legend taking the reins full-time. That emotional arc resonates with fans sick of managerial merry-go-rounds.
Experience is the chief concern. Carrick has never managed a top club at this level before. The Premier League’s tactical minefield is littered with managers who couldn’t adjust when games broke down or when opposition threw curveball formations at them.
United’s expectations are sky-high. The last manager to win the title here was Sir Alex Ferguson, and Carrick has nowhere near the resume of experienced coaches United could hire. If the club’s board decide they need a proven elite manager rather than a bridge to stability, Carrick could be bypassed.
Verdict: Carrick’s edge is real — but temporary. His odds reflect the now, not the future.
Min. Deposit: £/€10 – Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus money within 30 days / 50x Wager any winnings from the free spins within 7 days.
← CLICK TO COPY
From a tactical standpoint, Oliver Glasner represents the kind of modern, organised manager United could thrive under. Known for solid defensive structures, flexible formations, and a disciplined midfield shape, his teams rarely capitulate under pressure.
He’s also shown the ability to bring the best out of players not previously considered elite, which fits United’s current squad dynamic — a mix of young talent and experienced pros needing clear guidance.
Glasner’s approach is methodical rather than flamboyant, something that could restore much-needed defensive stability without sacrificing attacking talent.
The biggest question mark around Glasner is brand appeal and big-club experience. United’s global stature means the manager isn’t just a coach but an ambassador; someone media, sponsors, and fans can rally around.
While Glasner ticks the tactical box, there are doubts whether he can manage the off-field pressure that comes with a job like United’s. Premier League intensity is also a step up from mid-table European leagues, and critics may question whether his style is pragmatic to a fault.
Verdict: A strong tactical choice, but carries risk in the big moments.
Gareth Southgate’s name rarely leaves the managerial rumour mill. He’s proven he can manage elite talent under a microscope, navigate media scrutiny, and nurture young players — all while representing a nation’s identity.
At England he balanced expectations and pressure with relative pragmatism. Southgate knows how to handle players like Marcus Rashford, Bruno Fernandes, and rising stars. His emphasis on culture and communication fits a United rebuild that prioritises cohesion over chaos.
For fans craving a leader who embodies calm, tactical awareness, and a long-term plan, Southgate ticks many boxes.
The flip side is that Southgate has often been criticised — fairly or not — for being too cautious in big games. United’s playing squad bristles with attacking talent, and supporters might bristle at a manager who manages for draws rather than wins by daring.
There’s also the stumbling block of leaving the England job mid-cycle, which could generate public backlash and complicate negotiations.
Verdict: Southgate has credibility, but carries the risk of being perceived as risk-averse.
Min. Deposit: £/€10 – Wager from real balance first. 50X wager the bonus money within 30 days / 50x Wager any winnings from the free spins within 7 days.
← CLICK TO COPY
If you want a heavyweight manager with a track record of silverware at elite clubs, Thomas Tuchel is near the top. Champions League success, domestic trophies, and the ability to squeeze every ounce of performance out of top players — this is classic “big club manager” pedigree.
Tuchel commands respect. He’s strategic, adaptable, and has navigated high-pressure environments at clubs like Chelsea, PSG, and Bayern Munich.
United’s current squad has the talent to win big — if a manager can unlock it. Tuchel can do that.
The biggest issue with Tuchel is control. Few managers exert more influence on transfers, training, and club vision. United’s board and sporting directors would need to grant him wide latitude — and it’s unclear if that’s on the table.
He’s also had public clashes with players and hierarchy in the past. While passion can spark success, United need stability — the opposite of intra-club disputes.
Verdict: A high-risk, high-reward pick. Tuchel could be transformational, or combustible.
Julian Nagelsmann is widely regarded as one of the brightest tactical minds in world football. His ability to switch formations mid-game, exploit opposition weaknesses, and foster young talent — that’s elite manager DNA.
At United, Nagelsmann’s vision could accelerate the tactical evolution needed to compete with Manchester City’s Guardiola-inspired machine or Liverpool’s intense transitional play.
His cerebral approach might also mesh well with United’s mix of youth and experience.
Nagelsmann’s price tag (both in transfer-style compensation and salary) is a massive hurdle. United would have to convince him that Old Trafford is the perfect next step at exactly the right moment — which might be difficult with his career options.
Plus, his tactical complexity sometimes leads to over-engineered games where instinct is stifled by analysis. At a club craving identity as much as innovation, that could be problematic.
Verdict: A future star for sure — whether that future is at United remains to be seen.
Roberto de Zerbi is a lover’s choice. His teams play possession-based, proactive football, prioritising short passes, movement, and intelligence. For fans tired of bland pragmatic approaches, de Zerbi’s style is a feast.
He’s also improved players individually, helping them reach peak performance within his system. A United team that plays beautifully and wins? That’s seductive.
Execution at the highest level is a different beast. De Zerbi’s philosophy demands precision — and when it falters, his teams can look lost. United’s squad has the talent but not always the discipline required for his style.
There’s also the question of whether United’s hierarchy would back such a clear tactical identity over immediate results.
Verdict: A high-reward stylistic choice, but risky.
Pochettino is almost a default suggestion whenever a big job is vacant. He’s charismatic, develops young players well, and has managed elite clubs with mixed resources.
At his best, Pochettino demands intensity, organisation, and a robust team spirit — something United could use.
His last few managerial spells have been inconsistent. At some clubs he struggled to find a clear identity or adapt when games aren’t going his way.
For a club as impatient as United, that unpredictability is a concern.
Verdict: A respected figure — but perhaps not the transformational appointment United need right now.
Kovac brings European managerial experience and a reputation for discipline and organisation. He’s not a household name globally, which means lower pressure, and he could focus purely on rebuilding United without media spectacle.
His style is more traditional and less innovative than other contenders. United fans and pundits might query whether Kovac has the tactical firepower needed to compete at the elite Premier League level.
Verdict: A dark horse — but unlikely unless the market pivots dramatically.
After weighing all contenders, my pick for the next permanent Manchester United manager is … Oliver Glasner.
While Michael Carrick has the edge now due to his temporary control and the sentimental narrative of a club legend stepping up, the board will likely look for experience plus upside for the permanent role. Carrick checked the stability box, but United need evolution, not just steadiness.
Southgate would be a safe, popular choice, but his perceived caution may clash with United’s need for attacking ambition. Tuchel has elite pedigree, but comes with volatility United might not currently want. Nagelsmann and de Zerbi are exciting but unproven at this level and cost. Pochettino feels like a previous generation’s “default,” and Kovac lacks the tactical punch for a club of United’s stature.
Glasner, in contrast, offers tactical balance, discipline, and potential for growth — a blend United desperately needs.
A managerial change will reshape:
For continual updates on Premier League managerial news, transfer rumours, and Manchester United updates, keep checking BonusReferrerCode.com’s dedicated sections:
Manchester United’s next permanent manager won’t just inherit a seat — they’ll inherit a legacy, expectation, and a fanbase that demands excellence. Whether it’s a legend turned manager like Carrick, a tactical maestro like Glasner, or a global superstar name like Tuchel or Southgate, the decision will define the club’s next era.
For now, the ball remains in the club’s court — but based on odds, fit, and long-term vision, Oliver Glasner feels like the best bet to become the next permanent Manchester United manager.
18+ Always remember to gamble responsibly. Check out bet365’s Safer Gambling page for more details or go to GambleAware.org for advice, tools and support.
#AD Bonus Referrer Code is an affiliate of the brands we promote throughout this site. While we strive to maintain accuracy throughout our content, we do receive compensation for this promotion.
Check out our Premier League Scoreboard – A look back at the key results and games from the last Premier League weekend!
Predict your way to a prize of up to a £250,000 on bet365 6 Scores Challenge game!
Check out the top betting tips for Champions League Matchday 8 for all six English teams participating.
bet365 UCL Tournament Challenge – Get the lowdown on this free to play UCL game at bet365!
Worried about your gambling? When the fun stops – STOP!
